Is the ‘Joker’ on Us?

Is the ‘Joker’ on Us?

Is the ‘Joker’ on Us?

The thrill main as much as the discharge of Joker has been as bipolar and chaotic as the enduring villain himself. Some critics have praised the Todd Phillips-directed Batman spinoff, which received the highest prize and obtain an eight-minute standing ovation on the Venice Movie Competition in August. Others detest the movie, for varied causes: it “lionizes and glamorizes” the villain; it’s “an anthem for incels”; “a toxic story for a fraught time.” 

One can think about the Joker cackling with glee on the chaos this rendering of his story has brought about, scary audiences from each path. It’s precisely what he’d need. As we struggle over Joker’s which means and get triggered by it in a panoply of the way, the filmmakers are laughing all the way in which to the financial institution.

All motion pictures are mirrors, even after we don’t like what we see in it, and even when the film isn’t notably considerate about how and what it displays. Joker displays us, and our cultural second, in methods we’d do nicely to contemplate. 

Are You Not Entertained?

What does it say about us {that a} grim, disaster-in-the-making origin story concerning the world’s most well-known comic-book villain will seemingly be one of many highest-grossing motion pictures of the yr? Why will we flock to see the making of a psychopath, with gleeful anticipation for the bloody spectacle we all know will conclude the movie (and which some folks clapped for, fairly disturbingly, within the theater the place I noticed it)?

It’s the identical cause why we are able to’t look away from a fiery automotive wreck on the freeway, or why we are sometimes glued to the TV through the newest terrorist bombing, mass taking pictures, or pure catastrophe. It’s why the O. J. Simpson trial and Gulf Conflict principally invented cable information. It’s why the gradual devolution on Breaking Dangerous was completely fascinating to observe. It’s why horror is probably the most bankable Hollywood style. One thing in us is concurrently repulsed by and interested in the macabre, the grotesque, the horrifying. 

The primary phrases we hear in Joker are “the news never ends,” and all through the movie the press protection of Gotham’s crime figures prominently. A stunning act of violence on stay tv catalyzes the movie’s climax, bringing to thoughts latest movies like Christine (2016) and Nightcrawler (2014), which have explored the intersection of media and violence (“if it bleeds, it leads”).

Why are we—dare I say it—entertained by watching destruction and calamity unfold? I embody myself in these questions. Why did I discover Well being Ledger’s Oscar-winning portrayal of the Joker in The Darkish Knight (2008) each deeply unsettling and form of cool? When he walks away from the exploding hospital carrying a nurse’s outfit, or wields a bazooka from a dashing semi, audiences enjoyment of his glam-goth type and plain showmanship. Definitely there are moments in Joker the place Joaquin Phoenix—albeit a extra clumsy, nerdy, and fewer assured Joker—channels that very same underworld swagger. 

The Joker, like Devil himself, is aware of that people are inherently perverse creatures, lured in by spectacle, hooked on novelty, vulnerable to amusing ourselves to loss of life. On this method Joker is the right bogeyman for our age, embodying the poisonous, corrosive energy of an entertainment-obsessed, hyper-mediated society of spectacle

Joker is the right bogeyman for our age, embodying the poisonous, corrosive energy of an entertainment-obsessed, hyper-mediated society of spectacle

If we really feel gross being “entertained” watching the Joker’s darkish descent (and in Joaquin Phoenix’s fingers it really is a fascinating spectacle), it’s precisely the sensation Philipps needs to evoke. As we watch the grotesque and oft-repeated slow-mo sequences of this homicidal maniac dancing to Frank Sinatra, we should always ask ourselves: Is that this what entertains us at this time? Why?

For Christians particularly, the questions appear pressing: Why are portrayals of evil and brokenness so compelling,  even “cool”? May this be one manifestation of our tradition’s elevated emphasis on the “badge of honor” worth of brokenness, relatability, and #nofilter “authenticity”? It’s more durable to establish with “good guys” lately, if we even belief that good guys exist. However the fragility and darkness of Arthur Fleck in Joker—now that we are able to relate to. If it’s even partially true {that a} transparently damaged, “I’m a mess” villain like Fleck is extra compelling and identifiable to audiences than a extra steady, morally pushed hero, then the Joker is actually on us. 

Why So Critical?

Maybe probably the most iconic line from Ledger’s Darkish Knight Joker, “Why so serious?” might be requested of Joker, a movie that, in contrast to its comic-book kin, isn’t very enjoyable in any respect. Certainly, the movie’s bleak aesthetic—a seedy, early 1980s Gotham that invokes Martin Scorsese’s Taxi Driver—fosters a tone of gloom that feels becoming for our cultural second. However the “why so serious?” query may be turned on us.

The seething anger and joyless nihilism on the coronary heart of Joker is apt for our “American carnage” second, is it not? If Joker makes a fetish out of rage and cynicism, it’s solely as a result of that is what our media atmosphere does too. If Joker thinks it’s extra essential than it’s, “a venture drowning in self-seriousness,” it’s solely as a result of that is our every day bread on social media: the place everybody’s sizzling take appears (to them) crucial, and the place each new outrage is of utmost urgency. 

At the moment’s world is continuously indignant, every little thing is politicized, and something remotely pleasurable is shortly suffocated underneath the burden of piled-on chastisement and woke deconstruction. Virtually something well-liked or nice will inevitably encourage waves of backlash, then backlashes to the backlash, and so forth. Takes upon takes upon takes. It’s exhausting. 

To make certain, leisure may be culturally astute and “relevant”; actually there are essential points we’d like artwork, and criticism, to have interaction. However Christians particularly ought to struggle for the worth of pleasure, pleasure, leisure, enjoyment, magnificence—issues which can be useful exactly as a result of they’re typically irrelevant. A world with no time or house for such issues—the place every little thing is a battle, subtext, and commentary—is a world the place an considerable, grace-giving, Sabbath-creating God will really feel more and more distant and undesirable.

Explaining Away Evil

Talking of a distant God, that is one other method Joker holds up a mirror to our cultural second. It’s a film that continues the development of Christopher Nolan’s Batman movies: superhero motion pictures the place the supernatural is conspicuously absent. It’s a world the place good and evil as transcendent classes don’t exist and thus, as Alissa Wilkinson factors out, “the terror of the Joker is curiously defanged.”

Certainly, even in Nolan’s in any other case soul-less Darkish Knight universe, Ledger’s Joker is undeniably evil: disturbing as a result of he doesn’t have a backstory; an unstoppable drive with no obvious whence or wither, rhyme or cause. However in Joker, Philipps and Phoenix take nice pains to clarify Joker’s evil. To not justify or defend it, to make sure, however to situate it inside an immanent world the place horrific conduct should be the impact of some pure trigger. 

It’s fascinating that earlier this yr Phoenix starred as Jesus within the terrible Mary Magdalene, a movie that grounded Jesus in a completely immanent, disenchanted world, simply as Joker grounds its devilish villain in a human and humble context. Taking part in each side of the good-and-evil spectrum, Phoenix is actually fascinating to observe; his appearing chops are formidable. However to over-nuance evil in Joker is silly. I’m not even certain Phoenix or Phillips would use the phrase “sin” to explain what’s happening with Fleck. By giving such a logical, “here’s why he went bad” spin to Joker’s story, the movie displays a society that struggles to know what to do with evil.

As scary because it generally is, Joker made me consider the (far scarier) Las Vegas bloodbath in 2017. It’s the deadliest mass taking pictures in U.S. historical past, however the lone perpetrator had no obvious motive. In a secular age, we don’t know what to do with this. It doesn’t make sense. We’re determined to seek out containable causes for evil conduct, as a result of the choice—that our fallen nature means any of us might develop into a villain too—is for some too unsettling.

There are lots of mirrors in Joker—many pictures of Fleck taking a look at himself, his clown make-up smeared by blood and tears. However the ghastly photographs of Fleck are much less disturbing that what the movie displays again to us: a society unusually intoxicated by macabre spectacles however oddly immune to confronting the realities of evil, least of all in our personal hearts. 

Is the ‘Joker’ on Us?

Get involved!

Get Connected!

Come and join our community. Expand your network and get to know new people!


No comments yet