Progressive Christianity: Even Shallower Than the Evangelical Faith I Left

In John 6, Jesuss onerous instructing causes numerous his followers to desert him. After they go away, Jesus asks his remaining disciples, Do you need to go away as nicely? (v. 67). Peter, whom I assume is heartbroken and embarrassed from seeing so many he is aware of go away the one he calls Lord, speaks up: Lord, to whom we could go? You’ve got the phrases of everlasting life, and we have now believed, and have come to know, that you’re the Holy One in every of God (vv. 6869).

That is my story, too. I’ve walked in each sneakers: the sneakers of those that abandoned and the sneakers of Peter who couldnt go away, irrespective of how onerous it appeared to remain. I used to be an #exvangelical who left the religion of my youth for progressive Christianity. Then I returned. Heres my #revangelical story.

How My Religion Crumbled

The Christian custom I grew up infor all of the fantastic issues it gave mewas not ready for a era of children with entry to high-speed web. Not that the critiques of the Bible we found on-line had been new, however they had been now on the fingertips of curious people who grew up in evangelical bubbles. Like me. The solutions given in church appeared shallow in comparison with the authentic critiques that had been a Google search or YouTube video away.

  • What concerning the contradictions and scientific inaccuracies in sure biblical tales?
  • How have we shrugged on the passages the place God instructions Israel to slaughter their enemies and their enemies’ youngsters?
  • How might a loving God condemn his beloved creation to everlasting torment? What about all the opposite religions? Arent all of them saying principally the identical factor?

These questions, amongst others, started to chip away on the authority of the tales I used to be handed as a baby.Not solely did I’ve questions concerning the Bible, I additionally had questions on the way it squared with my religion’s political tradition:

  • Why did our insurance policies appear to notably drawback poor and marginalized communities?
  • Why was it widespread within the church to see Christians degrade immigrants, made within the picture of God, who had been merely searching for a greater life in my Texas city?
  • As necessary as abortion is, certainly we’re supposed care about these struggling after beginning as nicely, proper?

I couldnt assist however suppose it needed to be extra difficult than the story I used to be being advised. So ultimately,I left the religion utterly. I wished nothing to do with Jesus or the church.

I used to be an #exvangelical who left the religion of my youth for progressive Christianity. Then I returned. Heres my #revangelical story.

Curiously, it was in a time of mourningwhen I realized that my mom, from whom I’d been estranged, had diedthat God started to reenter my life. However my evangelical surroundings lacked a considerable theology of struggling. Struggling was one thing to keep away from or suppress, not a way of Gods remodeling grace in our lives.

This triangle of questionsabout Scripture, politics, and sufferinglaid the inspiration for me to discover progressive Christianity.

Deconstruction With out Reconstruction

I learn Rob Bells books Velvet Elvis and Love Wins. I learn Donald Millers Blue Like Jazz. I nonetheless keep in mind the paragraph from Blue Like Jazz that opened me as much as a world of grace I hadnt earlier than experiencedbut additionally to a world free of orthodox doctrine. As a fan of Michael Gungor, I started listening to his newly launched podcast, The Liturgists.

The views I encountered had been thrilling. Science didn’t should be discarded due to the Bible! When prayer felt like a coin toss, mysticism offered a brand new method to encounter the divine! Religion might encourage politics that included look after marginalized teams! Most significantly, in listening to Gungor and Science Mike McHargues tales of deconstruction, I heard my very own story. I discovered individuals who understood what it was prefer to deconstruct your religion and rebuild it from scratch.

However then I bumped into an issue. As I stored listening and studying, I spotted I didnt have the instruments to rebuildand I wasnt receiving any from these voices. Each perception I held had been neatly disassembled and laid naked on the ground for examination. However there was no steerage for placing one thing again collectively. Serving to folks deconstruct their religion with out additionally serving to put it again collectively once more is lazy, irresponsible, harmful, and isolating. The aim of deconstruction needs to be larger faithfulness to Jesus, not mere self-discovery or signaling ones advantage.

The aim of deconstruction needs to be larger faithfulness to Jesus, not mere self-discovery or signaling ones advantage.

As The Liturgists journeys progressed, they grew to become more and more lockstep with the progressive platform of the political Left. It jogged my memory of the conformity of conservative Christians to regardless of the Republican Occasion advised them to imagine. When the 2016 election ended, I had an odd expertise. I shared the progressives’ concern for the nation, however I additionally noticed them utilizing the identical litmus assessments that the conservative evangelicals of my youth had usedjust now on the opposite aspect of the aisle. Now, if you happen to held to a historic Christian sexual ethic, you had been a backwards bigot. If you happen to thought-about abortion morally incorrect, you had been anti-woman.

Progressives had change into simply as fundamentalist because the fundamentalists they despised. Solely now, as an alternative of conventional values being the litmus check, it was wokeness. If you happen to didnt tow the social gathering line of progressive orthodoxy, you had been an outcast. A heretic.

‘Progressive’ Model, Identical Superficial Pitch

I’d heard concerning the risks of moralistic therapeutic deism (MTD), the default American faith the place God merely desires you to reside a good life and never be unhappy, and doesnt intrude in your life. I initially ran to progressive Christianity to counter that form of shallow perception. However what I discovered was simply extra of the identical, solely with new definitions.

Wokeness was the brand new morality. Remedy was the brand new path to happiness. Cancel tradition was the brand new church self-discipline. And like MTD, there was, conveniently, no private God to position calls for in your life in any significant means. On this progressive MTD, Elizabeth Gilberts trope is the one factor left: God dwells inside you, as you. There’s no method to distinguish between ourselves and God. On this paradigm, we are God.

Progressives had change into simply as fundamentalist because the fundamentalists they despised. However as an alternative of conventional values being the litmus check, it was now wokeness.

Im not anti-woke or anti-therapy. Systemic injustice is actual, and we’d like the conversations that wokeness has introduced us. I used to be in remedy for nearly two years whereas in faculty, and I feel it could actually profit virtually everybody.

However these should not satisfactory replacements for the everlasting love of the triune God.

Mark Sayers describes the progressive imaginative and prescient of the world as the dominion with out the King. We would like all of Gods blessingswithout submitting to his loving rule and reign. We would like progresswithout his presence. We would like justicewithout his justification. We would like the horizontal implications of the gospel for societywithout the vertical reconciliation of sinners with God. We would like society to adapt to our customary of ethical puritywithout Gods customary of non-public holiness.

Journey Again to Orthodox Religion

After the 2016 election I grew to become satisfied it was time to start rebuilding my religion. A number of months later, two issues occurred concurrently: I started formal theological schooling and, in a tragic accident, I misplaced the grandfather who had raised me. This dying plunged me into one other season of intense struggling, however this time in a theologically rigorous surroundings.

One in every of my lecturers mentioned, We do theology within the gentle so we are able to stand on it at nighttime. I used to be doing theology and standing on it at nighttime. For the primary time I actually realized the doctrines of the Trinity and of Scripture as a unified story, and how you can learn it as impressed literature. I used to be taught how doctrines that I assumed had been contradictorylike penal substitution and Christus Victoractually want one another to kind the total, lovely, biblical image. I realized about union with Christ and all of the blessings it brings. I realized about religious disciplines and the life-giving freedom that flows from a disciplined pursuit of God. From there, the broad and wealthy world of historic Christian orthodoxy swung open for me to discover.

My story is hardly distinctive. The truth is, it’s changing into increasingly more widespread.

My petition to pastors, then, is twofold:

1. As Jude says, Have mercy on those that doubt (1:22). Don’t meet doubts or questions or considerations with harshness, dismissiveness, or shallow solutions. Be affected person with onerous questions, and work together with your folks for complete, nuanced solutions.

2. Train the richness of the Christian custom. Dont accept feel-good MTD platitudes as steerage for a greater life. Give difficult solutions to difficult questions. Present how Jesus, probably the most sensible particular person to ever reside, speaks to each side of life and society with compassion, love, and charm.

We’d like extra theology, nuance, grace, compassion, and understanding in our church buildings, not much less. However this stuff are made attainable by orthodox doctrine, not despite it. Doubt and questions needn’t catalyze a pendulum swing from perception to unbelief. If labored out in wholesome, considerate Christian communityand with an abiding connection to Christ, our true vine (John 15)they will really deepen religion and strengthen roots, producing a life the place we bear fruit and face up to the fierce winds of a secular age.

We’d like extra theology, nuance, grace, compassion, and understanding in our church buildings, not much less.

Everyones religion journey is winding and sophisticated. However God is God and his path stays, even when weve wandered off it for a time. There are extra paths than ever earlier than in todays worldmore choices for religious enlightenment or curate-your-own-beliefs religion. However no path results in true happiness and eternal life besides the Jesus alone path (John 14:6), which is narrower than we’d like (Matt. 7:13) however extra satisfying than we are able to think about (Ps. 16:11).

In my journey I found, with Peter, that God’s divine energy has granted to us all issues that pertain to life and godliness, by means of the data of him who known as us to his personal glory and excellence (2 Peter 1:3). In Christ, we have now all the things we’d like. Why go away the boundaries of religion as soon as for all delivered to the saints (Jude 1:3) with the intention to discover life? Jesus has the phrases of life. He is life. Reality. The best way. The place else would we go?


Leave a Reply