Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?

When Jessi Vos was a junior in highschool, she informed her mother and pa she wished to go to a school that was extra worldwide and extra city than the Iowa city the place she grew up.

She additionally wished a spot that wasn’t too massive—her state college felt enormous—and Christian professors and a Christian campus. (“I’ve learned that a Christ-centered education is the most important thing to me in pursing my college career,” she wrote on one utility.)

Her mother and father wished all of that for her, too.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?
Courtesy of MarketWatch

“I remember spending time in prayer, saying, ‘Please don’t put my kid or us into a situation where they find the perfect college and we simply can’t afford it,’” her mom, Teri, stated. “I talk to parents who say they will figure out a way to make the financial piece work, because you can’t put a price tag on helping your kid be in the best environment possible at this stage of life. But even so, there is going to be a point at which that doesn’t work.”

She’s not unsuitable. The common value of 1 yr of school—together with tuition, charges, room, and board—at an American college doubled between 1988 and 2016, from $11,509 (adjusted for inflation) to $23,091. The worth development was eight instances sooner than the speed of wage development throughout that interval.

Amongst members of the Council for Christian Schools and Universities (CCCU), the associated fee is considerably greater—$35,488 a yr (although considerably lower than the typical four-year, personal, nonprofit schools’ price ticket of $44,551).

You’d suppose Christian schools can be hiring new employees, elevating salaries, and beginning new applications. The truth is, you’d suppose directors can be shopping for yachts and professors can be buying trip houses within the Virgin Islands.

The common value of 1 yr of school at an American college doubled between 1988 and 2016, from $11,509 (adjusted for inflation) to $23,091.

However that’s not what’s occurring.

“The financial health of many Christian institutions of higher education is more precarious than ever before,” Trinity Worldwide College president David Dockery wrote within the Christian Schooling Journal this yr. “The rise of costs, the challenge of financial aid, changing tax laws, and unpredictability of funding streams point toward questions regarding long-term viability.”

“There is a real looming crisis, that’s for sure,” stated New Saint Andrews Faculty president Ben Merkle. He remembers being at CCCU assembly the place the approaching monetary future was likened to “driving off a cliff.”

The truth is, the state of affairs is worse than Dan Nelson, who has spent the final 20 years surveying monetary information for CCCU colleges, has ever seen it earlier than.

So what provides? If Christian schools are charging greater than they ever have, why are their checking account balances so low?


It might be that Christian schools value extra however are attracting fewer college students, so that they’re making much less cash.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?That might make sense. However it’s not what’s occurring.

Whereas some colleges—particularly these in areas of the nation which might be shedding inhabitants, akin to Illinois—are struggling to keep up enrollment, others are rising. They usually’re gaining greater than the declining schools are shedding.

General, CCCU colleges’ complete headcount rose from about 425,000 in 2012 to almost 448,000 in 2017. (Full-time pupil enrollment rose much less, from about 302,000 to about 309,000.)

That development is mirrored in each the bigger personal nonprofit sector and in addition in public universities. Over the previous 20 years, solely the for-profit class has misplaced college students, dropping sharply since 2010 after working into a number of lawsuits, unfavorable publicity, and tighter federal laws.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?
Numbers from the Nationwide Middle for Schooling Statistics

The truth is, it looks like attracting college students to Christian schools ought to be fairly straightforward. Whereas fertility charges are dropping, Christians nonetheless have infants at the next degree than substitute fee—sooner than every other spiritual group besides Muslims, in accordance to Pew Analysis Middle.

As well as, the speed of kids graduating from public excessive colleges is at an all-time excessive—85 p.c within the 2016–2017 college yr, in accordance to the Nationwide Middle for Schooling Statistics (NCES).

Most of them—about 70 p.c—enrolled in faculty in 2016. That quantity didn’t set a report however got here shut. That meant 19.eight million college students have been in faculty in fall 2016—positively down from the excessive of 20.6 million in 2012—when the for-profit colleges have been booming—however nonetheless greater than the 15.Three million in 2000 and even the 17.5 million in 2005.

So Christians are having infants, and excessive colleges are graduating college students, and people college students are going to varsity extra typically than ever earlier than. All the pieces ought to be nice, proper?


All the pieces was nice, for some time.

“The heyday of Christian higher education was probably from the early 1990s to about 2007,” stated Dockery, who was president of Union College in Tennessee for a lot of that point. At Union, enrollment grew for 16 straight years. The variety of donors tripled. The varsity added greater than seven undergraduate majors, six graduate applications, and 5 doctoral applications.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?
Dockery speaks on the dedication of the Carl Grant Occasions Middle in 2008.

“I don’t think we realized how privileged we were during those days,” he stated. “Enrollments were growing, budgets were increasing, and the Department of Education was friendly toward our efforts.”

That appeared to be true for many Christian schools. Membership within the CCCU—a community of Christian colleges based within the 1970s—doubled from 88 in 1994 to 176 (together with affiliate members) in 2006.

“As an association, it was a great run,” stated Bob Andringa, who led the CCCU throughout these years. The funds virtually tripled, from $3.eight million to $10.5 million, the employees jumped from 30 to 65, and the variety of applications and initiatives expanded to 90.

After which, in 2008, the housing bubble popped, the federal government needed to bail out the banks, and the economic system deflated. The unemployment fee jumped to 7.2 p.c.

On the face of it, this was extra excellent news for schools. Individuals who couldn’t discover a job headed to the classroom; the variety of incoming college students rose 12 p.c in 2008. At CCCU colleges, on common, each enrollment and tuition continued to climb.

However beneath the floor, the monetary basis of many Christian schools began to wobble.

Trojan Horse

In 1965, out of a need to make faculty extra reasonably priced to everybody, Congress handed the Greater Schooling Act. This regulation allowed the federal government to ensure pupil loans—mainly shifting the default threat from banks to taxpayers, which made banks extra prepared to lend to college students. In 1972, Congress adopted up with the creation of Sallie Mae, which purchased pupil loans from banks and finally handed out pupil loans itself.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (US), Pupil Loans Owned and Securitized, Excellent [SLOAS], retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Financial institution of St. Louis

The loans have been nearly unrestricted, as a result of the concept was to assist anyone who wished to go to varsity. Because the variety of college students going to varsity went up, tuition—which relies on what college students will pay—went up even sooner, and the federal government loaned out much more {dollars}.

In the course of the Nice Recession, unemployment, flattening wages, and plummeting house values made tuition funds uncomfortable and generally unimaginable. The default fee ballooned, and the Obama administration launched the “Pay As You Earn” compensation plan, which capped mortgage compensation and incentivized much more borrowing.

However it didn’t incentivize everybody.

CCCU college students take their loans critically. Their default fee is half the nationwide common (6 p.c versus about 12 p.c) and their compensation fee is noticeably greater (78 p.c in comparison with 65 p.c).

In the course of the Recession, the typical amount of cash borrowed by CCCU college students started to decelerate. In some instances, it dropped.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?
Courtesy of Bethel College

Correspondingly, the typical instructional debt of a CCCU graduate slowed as effectively.

“Starting with the recession, there was a shift in the attitudes of families in willingness to sacrifice to send their kid to their first-choice school,” stated Nelson, who’s the chief institutional information and analysis officer at Bethel College in Minnesota. “When Mom or Dad went out of work and they went from two incomes to one, they rethought how important it was to go to a higher-cost school.”

(Maybe not coincidentally, Dave Ramsey’s radio present, books, and lessons—which advise in opposition to borrowing for something besides a home—continued to skyrocket in reputation throughout this time.)

Christian mother and father began taking a look at inexpensive choices. By 2018, practically half of responding CCCU colleges (46 p.c) informed a Bethel College survey {that a} public college was their No. 1 competitors.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?“We know people who don’t want their child to look at out-of-state schools because they’re more expensive,” dad or mum Teri Vos stated. “They say the same thing about private education vs. public universities.”

Which means Christian faculty recruiters should work more durable.

“My stars, the enrollment operation of liberal arts colleges 40 years ago was to have a couple young graduates who would go out and get your next class,” stated Paul Corts, former president of Wingate Faculty, Palm Seashore Atlantic College, and the CCCU. Now “the cost of attracting a student is very high.”

A part of that value is the campus.

“It’s an arms race,” Dockery stated. “We all had to do what we needed to compete.” Schools upgraded their expertise and constructed new dorms, lecture rooms, and gymnasiums.

At Union, pupil flats provide personal bedrooms, two bogs, and a washer and a dryer. (“They’re spectacular,” Dockery stated. “That helped us recruit students.”) At Lee College, a “gorgeous new state-of-the art building with all the robotic equipment” was constructed for nursing majors, president Paul Conn stated. This system, which didn’t exist 5 years in the past, now has 400 majors.

Among the upgrades have been carried out pre-recession, when budgets have been deep within the black, and it appeared like enrollment would ever solely develop. Some have been carried out later, in an often-successful bid to draw high-school seniors.

However “all that drove up the price,” Dockery stated. Not a lot for the development itself—that was typically paid for with capital campaigns—however for ongoing maintenance. “Now we hit a price point, and a lot of parents won’t pay.”

“We’ve overbuilt,” Nelson stated.

However that’s not even the largest drawback.

Pupil Support

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?In the course of the Nice Recession, the p.c of “needy” CCCU candidates rose dramatically, from a median of 67 p.c in 2007–2008 to 77 p.c in 2012–2013. Whereas the quantity later dipped, it stays considerably greater than pre-recession ranges.

A part of that was their mother and father’ means to put in writing tuition checks, which took a pointy dip in 2008 after which leveled off for just a few years earlier than starting to climb once more in 2014. However by then, tuition fee will increase had left wage will increase within the mud.

So colleges saved sweetening the deal. The common CCCU low cost fee—or the quantity given to college students as grants and scholarships—rose steadily from round 32 p.c in 2006–2007 to 47 p.c in 2018–2019. (Different personal schools have taken this identical route—the typical low cost fee for incoming freshmen at personal, not-for-profit American universities for the 2017–2018 college yr was 50 p.c.)

It’s not that Christian excessive schoolers are pitting CCCU colleges in opposition to one another, although in fact the monetary packages they get do weigh into their choices. Greater than that, “there is increased aggressiveness from public higher education,” Conn stated. “When I was first president [in 1986], the state schools were almost like public utilities that provided a service to the public. They didn’t have the entrepreneurial model. But they do now.”

The common CCCU low cost fee has risen to 47 p.c.

Conn tells his recruiters, “Proper now, our prospects are getting calls from different colleges—Kennesaw State College, College of North Carolina, Center Tennessee State College. Mother and father are pondering, You’ll be able to go there with a mix of state grants and somewhat extra cash. That’s most likely what we should do.”

It’s the Christian mother and father who’ve been by means of the method who’re somewhat savvier when fascinated about faculty prices.

“We’ve learned that the initial price tag you see online and on the paperwork is not necessarily where you’ll land,” Vos stated. The vary of scholarships—from athletic to tutorial to management to music to theater to simply “the average student”—is so vast that “whatever the price tag, no matter your student, [the final cost] can change so much.”

Perhaps an excessive amount of. All that assist implies that many faculties are giving freely scholarships and grants sooner than they increase their costs.

“This is the cause of our schools’ discontent,” Nelson stated. “Prior to the recession, the amount of money they netted in a given year was going up by about 5 percent a year.”

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?That was about excellent. Nelson’s rule of thumb is {that a} faculty wants inflation plus 1.5 p.c—that additional p.c is as a result of schools spend most of their cash paying college and employees, who want raises—in income with a view to thrive. From 2000 to 2008, inflation bounced round Three p.c. Add the 1.5 and also you’re proper round 4.5 p.c to five p.c.

However now, “even with the increase of the family ability to pay in recent years, fully half of our schools are not even netting as much revenue as they did the year before,” Nelson stated.

That’s the crux of the disaster—with a view to entice college students, colleges are bringing in much less cash on account of discounted tuition whereas on the identical time spending extra on upgrades.

They usually haven’t even reached the cliff.

Beginning Charge Cliff

After World Conflict II, American GIs got here house, married their sweethearts, and began having infants.

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?From 1946 to 1961, the delivery fee skyrocketed. Eighteen years later, the variety of high-school graduates peaked at 3.1 million in 1977. (The quantity wouldn’t get that prime once more till 2007.)

What adopted was a bust, then smaller inhabitants bumps because the populous Boomers had youngsters after which grandchildren.

When the Nice Recession hit, the inhabitants of 18-year-olds had simply peaked and was coming into a seven-year decline—although enrollment was propped up by bigger percentages of these 18-year-olds going to varsity.

That decline lasted just a few years earlier than catching and transferring again up. For the previous 4 years, the pool of potential faculty freshmen has elevated.

However it’s straightforward to see why that enhance received’t final. In the course of the Nice Recession, like practically all  different instances of economic stress, People had fewer infants. That fee hasn’t picked again up; in Might, the Facilities for Illness Management introduced that 2018 noticed the bottom variety of births in 32 years.

“What we see in California is that in 2026–2028 there will be a significant drop off in high-school graduates,” Biola College president Barry Corey stated. “If we mirror that, which we have for 60 years, that will affect us—unless we decide now that we’re going to do something different.”

One thing Totally different

In Might, Gordon Faculty introduced it was engaged on a 7 p.c funds reduce, which is able to embody eliminating 36 college and employees positions, consolidating philosophy/historical past/political science into one division, and reducing seven majors—together with chemistry, Spanish, and social work.

The varsity, together with different New England schools, is already going through the declining numbers of high-school graduates from decrease delivery charges in that space of the nation.

“The short story is that higher education is changing, and Gordon must adapt accordingly,” Gordon introduced. “Gordon is taking strategic steps to satisfy new market realities out of economic prudence and never out of economic misery. (In different phrases, we’re selecting to be proactive now slightly than ready to be inventive later, when monetary stress can be stronger.)”

Different Christian colleges are additionally selecting to consolidate or eradicate shrinking liberal arts departments and lean into STEM fields, the place the scholars are. Nonetheless others are including graduate applications, leaping into expertise fields, or transferring extra programs on-line.

We’ve got to suppose outdoors the field and be modern. We’ve got to consider, What’s the new frontier that’s related to our establishment, that matches who we’re?

“A few of us are pondering, Properly, we’ve turned up the dials as a lot as we are able to on conventional fashions,” Corey stated. “We will’t maintain growing our low cost fee or eradicate any extra fats or extra. We’ve got to suppose outdoors the field and be modern. We’ve got to consider, What’s the new frontier that’s related to our establishment, that matches who we’re?

He recommends colleges plan now, earlier than monetary stress means “you have no recourse but to do whatever the new thing is.”

“We’re all so tuition-driven that we have to respond to the market,” Dockery stated. “And that’s where the real tensions come, because where do you lose the mission in all of this? It’s not just a matter of surviving. It’s surviving faithfully.”

CCCU president Shirley Hoogstra calls it a “disrupted” time.

“We’re going from something familiar and predictable to something less predictable but on the edge of exciting,” she stated. She’s optimistic as a result of within the instability of the higher-education market, Christian schools have benefits: “Typically, they’re run with financially sound ideas. They usually have a unprecedented, distinct mission.

“Today’s problems are very complex, which is why I think Christian higher education is needed today more than ever,” she stated. “You can’t take out the spiritual components of society and life and expect to get the answers we need for the challenges we have.”

Tuition Is Rising and Enrollment Is Holding. So Why Are Christian Schools Struggling?

Get involved!

Get Connected!

Come and join our community. Expand your network and get to know new people!


No comments yet