What Does It Imply that Samuel Was Introduced Up from the Lifeless? (1 Samuel 28)

This text is a part of the Robust Passages collection.

Take heed to the Passage

Learn the Passage

11Then the lady stated, Whom shall I convey up for you? He stated, Deliver up Samuel for me. 12 When the lady noticed Samuel, she cried out with a loud voice. And the lady stated to Saul, Why have you ever deceived me? You might be Saul. 13 The king stated to her, Don’t be afraid. What do you see? And the lady stated to Saul, I see a god developing out of the earth. 14 He stated to her, What’s his look? And she or he stated, An previous man is developing, and he’s wrapped in a gown. And Saul knew that it was Samuel, and he bowed together with his face to the bottom and paid homage. 15 Then Samuel stated to Saul, Why have you ever disturbed me by bringing me up? Saul answered, I’m in nice misery, for the Philistines are warring in opposition to me, and God has turned away from me and solutions me no extra, both by prophets or by goals. Due to this fact I’ve summoned you to inform me what I shall do. 16 And Samuel stated, Why then do you ask me, because the Lord has turned from you and turn out to be your enemy? 17 The Lord has finished to you as he spoke by me, for the Lord has torn the dominion out of your hand and given it to your neighbor, David. 18 Since you didn’t obey the voice of the Lord and didn’t perform his fierce wrath in opposition to Amalek, subsequently the Lord has finished this factor to you this present day. 19 Furthermore, the Lord will give Israel additionally with you into the hand of the Philistines, and tomorrow you and your sons shall be with me. The Lord will give the military of Israel additionally into the hand of the Philistines. 20 Then Saul fell directly full size on the bottom, crammed with worry due to the phrases of Samuel. And there was no power in him, for he had eaten nothing all day and all night time.
1 Samuel 28:1120

Saul with out His Marketing consultant

1 Samuel 28:Three gives two items of data wanted to know the next narrative. First, the discover of Samuels demise and burial is repeated from 1 Samuel 25:1. Saul can now not seek the advice of the prophet for steering. The second a part of 1 Samuel 28:Three anticipates verse 1 Samuel 28:9. At an earlier stage Saul had acted in accordance with Mosaic legislation (Lev. 19:31; 20:27; Deut. 18:914) and had purged the land of those that practiced the occult. This was prevalent in surrounding nations however divinely proscribed as an abomination in Israel. A medium (Hb. ob) claimed to have the ability to conjure up and seek the advice of the spirit of a lifeless individual (additionally termed ob), maybe utilizing ventriloquism to persuade the gullible that they’d contacted the departed (cf. Isa. 8:19; 29:4). A necromancer (a realizing one) claimed to own data by entry to the spirits of the lifeless. Because the narrative later reveals (1 Sam. 28:7), Sauls efforts in coping with this phenomenon, as in different expressions of his dedication to the requirements of the Lord, fall in need of whole success.

A workforce of pastors and students walks by 6 historic books of the Outdated Testomony, displaying how they slot in with the remainder of redemptive historical past and Gods plan for his folks all through the ages.

The Philistines abandon their earlier technique of launching raids into the hill nation of Judah and as a substitute march north to grab management of the Valley of Jezreel, a key commerce route working east to west and itself wealthy agricultural land. In that open terrain they’ll deploy their chariot forces to good impact and so drive a wedge between Saul and the northernmost tribes. At first the invaders had mustered at Aphek (1 Sam. 29:1), the northernmost Philistine settlement, however right here they’ve superior an extra 44 miles (71 km) to Shunem, so chronologically this incident suits in after 1 Samuel 29. Shunem is on the north facet of the valley, whereas Gilboa is on the south, about 7.5 miles (12 km) away.

When Saul sees the Philistine positions, he realizes the state of affairs is grim and has a premonition of the result. In mountainous territory the Israelite infantry would possibly maintain their very own, however that is open nation. Afraid echoes noticed (cf. touch upon 1 Samuel 23:15), and alongside together with his coronary heart trembled drastically (cf. 1 Sam. 13:7) is the primary of plenty of indications of fearfulness within the chapter.

Within the historic world, army commanders consulted the gods earlier than venturing into battle. Nonetheless, when Saul inquire[s] [yishal shaul; cf. comment on 1 Samuel 1:20] of the Lord, he meets with whole divine silence. Not one of the three acknowledged modes of divine communication perform as a result of the Lord refuses to talk to at least one who has already been rejected due to his disobedience (1 Samuel 15:26). Saul is searching for not a manner again to God however a approach to avert impending defeat.

Saul Providers a Medium

At his wits finish, Saul decides to make use of the companies of a lady who’s a medium (lit., a lady, mistress of a spirit).1 Such an individual would conduct sances during which it was claimed that the spirits of the lifeless might be contacted and the higher data they had been credited with could be disclosed (cf. 1 Sam. 28:15). Sauls determination to make use of the companies of a medium violates even his personal shallow understanding of the faith of the Lord and marks the ultimate step in his downfall (cf. 1 Chron. 10:1314). Sauls servants are military officers, two of whom subsequently accompany him on his go to (1 Sam. 28:8). They confirm that there’s a surviving medium at En-dor, presumably a Canaanite enclave within the territory of Manasseh (Josh. 17:1113). To get there from his camp Saul should move 6.2 miles (10 km) by enemy-controlled territory.

To flee the discover of the enemy in addition to his personal troops, and in addition to deceive the medium, the king removes his royal robes. With two companions he makes his approach to the medium by night time, which was presumably the same old time for sances however would additionally assist conceal his actions. He asks the lady to divine for me by a spirit [ob, ghost; cf. comment on 28:3]. Divine (cf. 1 Sam. 15:23) is essentially the most normal time period for participating in occult practices, and Saul is requesting a sance throughout which he’ll identify a selected particular person to be referred to as up from the realm of the lifeless.

The lady suspects her unknown customer could be an agent appearing for Saul, and so, with out conceding that she might do what has been requested, she reminds them of the royal coverage. Lower off implies a demise sentence, as required by Mosaic legislation (Lev. 20:27), and is a stronger time period than the sooner put or take away (1 Sam. 28:3), which might nonetheless go away open the potential for expulsion. The medium doesn’t need her alleged capability to contact the lifeless to result in her becoming a member of them prematurely.

Nonetheless, Saul is not going to settle for her refusal, and to reassure her he swears an oath. Though Because the Lord lives (cf. 1 Sam. 14:39) is a normal Israelite expression, its use on this context reveals how totally confused Sauls pondering has turn out to be. It’s sheer blasphemy to make use of the divine identify to ensure immunity to at least one participating in practices opposite to divine legislation.

Probably the style during which Saul speaks and the idea that he can indemnify people convinces the lady that she is coping with no abnormal customer. Whom shall I convey up for you? concedes that she will conjure up spirits. In his reply, Saul locations Samuel first for emphasis. Samuel is the prophet who had conveyed Sauls name to him and represented the certainties of the previous on which Saul has turned his again.

Sauls Response

The textual content is reticent in regards to the procedures the medium usesindeed, that she makes use of any at allnot simply to keep away from undue curiosity within the occult but in addition as a result of on this event her methods don’t contribute to the outcome. When the lady noticed Samuel, she cried out with a loud voice. Her shriek is an inarticulate gasp of astonishment at an incidence outdoors her management or expertise. In mild of her description of the apparition in 1 Samuel 28:13, it’s unbelievable that she acknowledges Samuel at this level. Nonetheless, regardless of her fright, the medium has been pondering arduous, and the sudden nature of the apparition leads her to determine Saul and accuse him of deception by not disclosing himself to her.

Saul is as excited because the medium is disturbed. Don’t be afraid is a perfunctory try to allay her fears, as a result of he doesn’t need the sance to finish prematurely. What do you see? reveals that at this stage Saul can see nothing himself. The language of the mediums reply is just not completely clear, neither is our understanding of what’s going down. I see a god developing out of the earth presumably signifies that from her heathen perspective the lady sees an imposing, preternatural determine that she takes to be divine. Up out of the earth displays the idea that Sheol, the realm of the departed, is situated underneath the world.

Saul nonetheless can not see something and has to ask, What’s his look? The mediums description is sufficiently distinctive for Saul to determine the determine as Samuel. An previous man describes Samuel by way of human frailty (definitely not the glory of Moses and Elijah in Luke 9:3031), and he’s sporting a gown, his attribute gown from boyhood (1 Sam. 2:19) that performed a big function in Sauls rejection (1 Sam. 15:2728). Maybe at this level Samuel turns into seen to Saul, who greets him with all deference and respect.

There aren’t any limitations to communication between Samuel and Saul, and the medium performs no half of their dialog. Certainly, the later got here to Saul (1 Sam. 28:21) opens up the likelihood that she is just not current at this level. Samuel upbraids Saul as a result of he has disturbed him by disrupting his mode of existence within the realm of the lifeless. Saul justifies his motion on the grounds of his nice misery; he’s at a loss to know the best way to deal with the Philistine menace. Extra considerably, there is no such thing as a confession of wrongdoing or previous rebel. Saul merely states, God has turned away from me and solutions me no extra. Although turned away is similar time period as departed (1 Sam. 16:14; 18:12), this doesn’t spur Saul to replicate on why God has not responded both by prophets or by goals. There isn’t any point out of the Urim (1 Sam. 28:6), maybe as a result of it raises recollections of Sauls bloodbath of the clergymen at Nob. However Saul has summoned Samuel as a result of he expects him to inform me what I shall do.

Why then do you ask me? is just not an encouraging response from Samuel. As soon as extra the usage of ask incorporates a play on Sauls identify (cf. touch upon 1 Sam. 28:6). In comparison with Sauls single point out of God in 1 Samuel 28:15, Samuel refers back to the Lord seven occasions in his reply. He has little question in regards to the Lords management of occasions. Repeating the verb utilized by Saul in 1 Samuel 28:15, Samuel uncompromisingly emphasizes that The Lord has turned [away] from you in covenant rejection. Change into your enemy spells out that the insurgent might anticipate no assist from the divine Overlord, or from Samuel as his spokesman.

Samuel gives Saul with no new info, as a substitute stressing that the present state of affairs is in accordance with what Samuel had, throughout his life, revealed to Saul. The Lord has torn the dominion out of your hand and given it to your neighbor repeats the decision Samuel delivered in 1 Samuel 13:14 and particularly 1 Samuel 15:28, with the precise addition of the identification of the neighborDavid.

Sauls circumstances are the product of his previous disobedience, echoing 1 Samuel 15:19. The identical verb is utilized in each didn’t perform and The Lord has finished this factor, linking the offense and the retribution imposed by God. This factor might be Gods refusal to reply to Saul: the one who has deserted God is deserted by him. God has withdrawn not solely prophetic steering but in addition assist for Sauls kingdom. Defeat awaits king and folks alike. Moreover, Saul and his sons will die the next day (cf. 1 Sam. 31:6), when they may be a part of Samuel in Sheol. The king appointed to defeat the Philistines (1 Sam 9:16) will die leaving Israel dominated by the Philistines.

Presumably Saul had maintained a kneeling place earlier than Samuel (1 Sam. 28:14), however on listening to this inexorable declaration he collapses full size on the bottom. The phobia-stricken king had been hoping in opposition to hope that Samuel would point out some approach to avert the looming catastrophe, however he has as a substitute bolstered its certainty and immediacyand then he apparently fades from the scene. And (lit., additionally or furthermore) introduces an extra issue past the crushing psychological blow: Saul can be bodily drained and exhausted, for he had eaten nothing all day and all night time, maybe to acquire divine favor by abstaining from meals (cf. 1 Sam. 14:24) or by lack of urge for food as a consequence of his nervousness.

Left to Face the Inevitable

In Sauls predicament, forsaken by God and Samuel, it’s the medium who acts with compassion. Trying on the king mendacity on the bottom, she noticed that he was terrifiedan intense and debilitating emotional response that overwhelms a person and leaves him unable to perform appropriately. Since she has risked her life to conform together with his calls for, he ought now to behave on her recommendation and eat to regain his power. The mediums sensible humanity is little question tinged with circumspect self-preservation: what would occur to her if the king died in her home? Sauls preliminary refusal is overcome by the insistence of his two attendants and the lady, who urged him (pressed him to reply; cf. 2 Sam. 13:25).

Finally he will get up from the bottom to sit down on the mattress, most likely right here a couch-like construction with a body, not merely a mat on the ground. The lady has a fattened calf within the stall in her home. She kills it and presumably boils or roasts a few of its meata particular delicacy in these days. Although she acts rapidly in getting ready it and baking bread, it’s no mere snack she gives however a meal match for a king. So for an hour or two Saul sits on the mattress, brooding over what has occurred. After Saul and his males ate, they rose and went away that night time. The scene performed in darkness ends in darkness (cf. v. 8; John 13:30). The God who’s mild had not blessed Saul, who’s left to face his inevitable finish the next day.


  1. A unique interpretation of this expression is offered by Tsumura (First E-book of Samuel, 630631), who argues that mistress refers back to the solar goddess who, through the night time, traverses and guidelines the subterranean realms of the lifeless and might convey again spirits of the departed from there. The medium would thus be a devotee of this goddess.

This text is customized from the ESV Expository Commentary: 1 Samuel2 Chronicles (Quantity 3) edited by Iain M. Duguid, James M. Hamilton, Jr., and Jay Sklar.

Well-liked Articles in This Sequence

Get involved!

Get Connected!

Come and join our community. Expand your network and get to know new people!


No comments yet